Why Is the J. Asthana or the Veeru Sahastrabuddhe Always the Baddy?
Have we become so accustomed to seeing students as victims and institutional heads as villains that we have forgotten to understand the other side of the story?
Think of two iconic Bollywood characters: Dr. J. C. Asthana from Munna Bhai M.B.B.S. and Professor Viru Sahastrabuddhe, popularly known as 'Virus', from 3 Idiots. Both were portrayed by the exceptionally talented Boman Irani. One was the Dean of a medical college, while the other was the Director of an engineering institute.
Both movies were brilliant in their own ways, carrying powerful social messages about education, learning, human values and the pressures of academic life. Yet, one common feature stands out. The head of the institution, the Dean or the Director, is portrayed as the principal antagonist, the person standing between the students and their happiness, aspirations and success.
Why is it that the person occupying the highest academic position is so frequently portrayed as the baddy?
Of course, cinema thrives on exaggeration, conflict and dramatic storytelling. But perhaps these portrayals also reflect a larger social perception: that students are always struggling, teachers are often insensitive, and institutional heads are the people who make life difficult for everyone.
But have we ever stopped to ask who these people really are?
The Dean was once a student too!
The Dean, Director or Principal was not born sitting in an administrative chair. He or she was once a first-year student, struggling with examinations, assignments, practicals, expectations and the uncertainties of a professional career.
They have experienced failures, disappointments, competition, financial constraints, social pressures and academic challenges. Some may have come from modest socioeconomic backgrounds, perhaps pursuing education through scholarships or with considerable sacrifices made by their families. Others may have been academically brilliant, but that does not necessarily mean their journey was without struggles.
I can relate to this personally. My graduation was not necessarily a story of uninterrupted academic success. I, too, experienced failures during my undergraduate years. I know what it feels like to be a student who does not always meet expectations. Today, as a Director of an educational institution, I also understand the other side of the table.
Perhaps our generation had a different support system. We had parents, siblings, extended families and friends who helped us navigate disappointments. Perhaps we had a greater ability to accept setbacks, or perhaps we simply learned to move forward despite them.
Today, however, even a negative comment, an unfavourable assessment or a disagreement can sometimes become a major emotional challenge for a student. We are increasingly concerned about anxiety, depression, academic stress and the ability of young people to cope with failure. These are genuine concerns and deserve empathy, understanding and appropriate support.
But does supporting students mean that we should eliminate every uncomfortable experience from their academic journey? Can education prepare someone for the real world if it does not also teach them how to face challenges?
The journey does not end with graduation.
When a student completes graduation, there is often a feeling of having mastered the subject. I remember feeling that way when I completed my physiotherapy graduation. However, when I completed my postgraduate education, I realised how much I did not know. The more I studied, the more I understood the vastness of the profession.
A postgraduate degree requires years of additional effort, specialisation and deeper understanding. A medical professional chooses a particular speciality because it is practically impossible to master every branch of medicine. An engineer develops expertise in a specific domain. Similarly, pursuing an MPhil or PhD requires an individual to undertake extensive academic work, research and critical enquiry in a highly specialised area.
The Dean or Director has travelled this journey. They have studied, qualified, specialised and worked towards reaching a position where they can contribute to the profession and society.
And now, they are expected to ensure that the next generation is equally competent, if not better.
Is the responsibility of an institutional head really that simple?
A student's immediate concern may be an examination, a practical assessment, an assignment or a particular teacher. But the person heading the institution has a much wider responsibility.
Admissions, recruitment, faculty development, infrastructure, salaries, academic quality, regulatory compliance, accreditation, student welfare, placements, institutional finances and the overall learning environment are just a few of the many responsibilities that need attention.
An institutional head must also ensure that every student receives an equitable opportunity to learn and that every faculty member is treated fairly.
And while doing all this, they must remain impartial.
It is important to understand that a Director or Dean cannot always make decisions that please everyone. An examiner assessing a student's performance cannot award marks simply because the student has worked hard or is emotionally distressed. An employee cannot expect professional growth without taking initiative and demonstrating competence.
This brings us to an important distinction: a teacher assesses performance; the student is responsible for demonstrating competence.
In competency-based education, the objective should not merely be to declare someone pass or fail. It should be to assess whether the learner has achieved the expected competencies. If the required level has not been achieved, the student must be given opportunities to improve, practise and demonstrate competence again.
This is particularly important in professional education.
Can we afford to pass a medical student who has not acquired the necessary clinical competence? Can we certify an engineer who cannot demonstrate the knowledge required to design a safe structure? Can we qualify a lawyer who has not developed the skills necessary to protect the rights of a client?
A medical professional's inadequate competence can affect a patient's life. An engineer's inadequate knowledge can compromise public safety. The consequences of poor professional preparation extend far beyond an examination result.
Therefore, maintaining academic standards is not an act of cruelty. It is an institutional and social responsibility.
Of course, this responsibility must be accompanied by fairness, transparency, appropriate teaching methods, constructive feedback and opportunities for remediation. Discipline should never become humiliation, and authority should never become an excuse for insensitivity.
Are we expecting a Guru or just another friend?
Our traditional philosophy places the teacher in an exceptionally respected position:
Guru Brahma, Guru Vishnu, Guru Devo Maheshwara.
The teacher is regarded as the creator, preserver and guide of knowledge and wisdom.
But somewhere along the way, have our expectations of teachers changed?
Do students want a mentor who will guide them, challenge them, correct their mistakes and help them build a career? Or do they expect a friend who will always agree with them, accommodate their preferences and make every academic experience comfortable?
There is absolutely nothing wrong with teachers being friendly, approachable and empathetic. In fact, an open and trusting relationship between a teacher and a student is essential for effective learning.
But friendship cannot replace mentorship, and being approachable does not mean compromising professional standards.
A student must also take responsibility for communicating their learning requirements. We often say that every individual is unique. Some students learn better through visual methods, some through listening, while others benefit from practical and tactile experiences. Understanding these differences and creating appropriate learning opportunities is the responsibility of an educator.
But communication must work both ways. Students must be willing to approach their teachers, express their difficulties, seek guidance and participate in their own learning journey.
No teacher enters an examination hall with the intention of failing students. A teacher's greatest satisfaction is seeing a student succeed, become a competent professional and contribute meaningfully to society.
Why do we glorify the anti-hero and overlook the real-life heroes?
Unfortunately, this perception is not restricted to educational institutions. In popular cinema, people occupying positions of authority are frequently portrayed negatively. Commissioners of police, ministers, doctors, institutional heads and other leaders are often depicted as corrupt, insensitive or self-serving.
Certainly, there are individuals in every profession who misuse their authority. There are teachers who are insensitive, administrators who are unfair and leaders who fail to fulfil their responsibilities. Such behaviour must be questioned and corrected.
But is it fair to generalise an entire profession based on a few negative examples?
What about the thousands of honest teachers, dedicated doctors, responsible engineers, committed police officers, sincere administrators and public servants who work tirelessly to make society better?
What about the janitors, drivers, attendants, clerical staff, accountants, nurses and countless other individuals whose contributions keep our institutions and society functioning?
How often do we celebrate them?
We readily glorify the cinematic anti-hero, but do we recognise the real-life heroes who quietly fulfil their responsibilities every day?
A message to students: We have been there. We understand.
Dear students, your teachers and institutional heads have been students too. They have appeared for examinations, faced failures, experienced disappointments and struggled to establish themselves professionally.
They may not always express their concerns in a way that you appreciate. They may sometimes be strict, demanding or unwilling to compromise. They may have to make decisions that you do not agree with.
But before concluding that they do not understand you, make an effort to understand their responsibilities as well.
And to my fellow educators and institutional leaders, this is equally a reminder that authority comes with accountability. We must listen, empathise, mentor and create an environment where students feel safe to express themselves. We must distinguish between discipline and punishment, and between correcting a student and hurting their dignity.
The responsibility of an educational institution is not merely to produce graduates. It is to develop competent, responsible and compassionate professionals.
I have realised one thing in life: You cannot please everybody, all the time. And perhaps, leadership is not about being liked by everyone; it is about doing what is right, even when it is not popular.
So, the next time you watch Dr. J. C. Asthana or Professor Veeru Sahastrabuddhe being portrayed as the baddy, pause for a moment.
Look beyond the stern expression, the disciplinary action and the unpopular decisions. There may be a teacher, a mentor and an administrator who is trying to build something much bigger than an individual's immediate happiness.
And perhaps, years later, when you become a doctor, engineer, lawyer, researcher, teacher or an institutional head yourself, you may understand what those decisions really meant.
If being the baddy means maintaining standards, upholding discipline, protecting professional competence and preparing students for the realities of life, then perhaps I would not mind being one.
After all, when a student succeeds, becomes a competent professional and makes a difference to society, the teacher's greatest reward is not applause or recognition.
It is the quiet satisfaction of knowing that the student has grown.
And perhaps, at that moment, the very same student who once thought the Dean was the villain will finally say:
Thank you, Sir. Now I understand.










